Services and Repair

Services and Repair

When you trust your jewelry repair with us, your work will be done by one of our three experienced bench jewelers in-house who are experts in their craft. We offer a quick turn around and even same day express service so you will not have to be without your jewelry far too long. We understand how important and personal your jewelry is to you and we believe an important part of being your jeweler is helping you take care of the jewelry you own so you can enjoy it for a lifetime.

About Us

About Us

Neugebauer`s Fine Jewelry has been serving the Black Hills area since 1945 with a solid tradition of excellence. We have been doing this for one reason. "To be your jeweler" Being your jeweler is more than selling you jewelry or designing a ring.

Custom Design

Custom Design

If you have a vision for something truly one-of-a-kind, our professional custom designers are here to serve you. You`ll find your favorite master designers here with the exquisite styles that you love and others admire. Brilliant diamonds, precious gems, birthstones, pearls, gold, white gold, silver and more await your approval. Indulge your refined taste with something new and timeless from Neugebauer`s. They will linesse the unique jewelry that will captivate you and amaze your friends. Stop by today to talk with them about your ideas.

Preferred Warranty 

Preferred Warranty 

Preferred Jewelers International™ is a nationwide network of premier independently owned and operated jewelry stores. This association guarantees that your Preferred Jeweler will give you...

“ Experiences that last a Lifetime™”


Figure Out the Engagement Ring Of Their Dreams

Protect the element of surprise in your proposal by stealthily gathering clues to the type of engagement ring they’re hoping for with these tips by Neugebauer’s Jewelry.

A man proposing to a woman on a hike. She is surprised and happy

When it comes to an engagement, the most crucial element is the love shared between the two parties. Make the moment special by surprising them with the ring of their dreams. Our team here at Neugebauer’s Jewelry has put together a list of tips to use all the resources available to you to figure out your partner’s engagement ring preferences without arousing suspicion.

Consider Their Personality

When shopping for the ideal engagement ring to propose to your partner, one of the most important things to consider is whether or not the rings you're deciding from reflect the personality of the one who will be wearing the ring. If your partner is demure and reserved, a bold, mixed metal, double halo ring with a vibrant gemstone serving as the center stone would feel off-key to them. In this situation, opt for a more minimalistic ring. A subtle solitaire with an elegant emerald cut diamond would be a better choice.

An oval cut ring with a halo of diamonds around the center stone on the hand of a woman sitting in her man's hand

Take Note of Their Jewelry Collection

Your partner’s existing jewelry collection is also a great place to look for inspiration. Pay special attention to the pieces they wear most often. First, take note of the type of metal they wear most often, as this can help determine the engagement ring metal they’d like the most. Observe the silhouettes and styles you frequently see in their favorite pieces.

Consult Their Friends and Family

Your partner’s closest family and friends are also indispensable allies when it comes to discerning the perfect type of engagement ring they will love. Entrust a few people with the information of your upcoming proposal, asking them to dig up any information they can. Perhaps they can ask your partner some leading questions about their hopes for a ring, but they must be careful not to raise any questions in your partner’s mind.

An open red ring box with an engagement ring presented to someone

Check Their Social Media

You can learn a lot about a person from their social media, including the types of bridal jewelry they’re interested in. Browse your partner’s social media accounts for any posts they may have liked or designers they may follow. If you’re lucky, your partner may even have a Pinterest board full of engagement ring inspiration.

Consider Their Unique Style

You can take note of how your partner dresses, how they decorate their home, and the types of art they tend towards to help you find their ideal ring. What sorts of color schemes do they prefer? What eras of fashion, architecture, or art inspire them? Take careful notes of these things and bring them to your jeweler, who happily guides you to the rings they feel would fit your future fiance’s style.

A woman wearing a red dress and black heels is in the arms of a man wearing formal wear

Shop Engagement Rings at Neugebauer’s Jewelry

At Neugebauer’s Jewelry, it would be our distinct pleasure to play a part in your unique love story by providing you with the engagement ring that will melt your partner’s heart. Our Rapid City jewelry store is stocked with a mesmerizing selection of designer rings wrought in the finest materials, sure to satisfy even the most discerning of tastes. Contact us today for more information on our products and services, or browse our inventory online at your convenience.


Track Order

Returning Customers

Sign in to your account to track orders and view your order history.

Quick Track

Don't have an account? Enter your order number and email address below to track your order.