Services and Repair

Services and Repair

When you trust your jewelry repair with us, your work will be done by one of our three experienced bench jewelers in-house who are experts in their craft. We offer a quick turn around and even same day express service so you will not have to be without your jewelry far too long. We understand how important and personal your jewelry is to you and we believe an important part of being your jeweler is helping you take care of the jewelry you own so you can enjoy it for a lifetime.

About Us

About Us

Neugebauer`s Fine Jewelry has been serving the Black Hills area since 1945 with a solid tradition of excellence. We have been doing this for one reason. "To be your jeweler" Being your jeweler is more than selling you jewelry or designing a ring.

Custom Design

Custom Design

If you have a vision for something truly one-of-a-kind, our professional custom designers are here to serve you. You`ll find your favorite master designers here with the exquisite styles that you love and others admire. Brilliant diamonds, precious gems, birthstones, pearls, gold, white gold, silver and more await your approval. Indulge your refined taste with something new and timeless from Neugebauer`s. They will linesse the unique jewelry that will captivate you and amaze your friends. Stop by today to talk with them about your ideas.

Preferred Warranty 

Preferred Warranty 

Preferred Jewelers International™ is a nationwide network of premier independently owned and operated jewelry stores. This association guarantees that your Preferred Jeweler will give you...

“ Experiences that last a Lifetime™”


Upgrade Your Engagement Ring

When To Upgrade Your Engagement Ring

Your engagement ring began the happily-ever-after of your marriage. However, over time, some people realize that they wish they had a different type of engagement ring, or they want to change at least one part of the design. The desire to upgrade one’s engagement ring could arise for a number of reasons, from improving outdated styles to choosing a larger center stone. Our team at Neugebauer’s Jewelry created a guide on popular ways to upgrade an engagement ring.

Upgrade to a Larger Diamond

Choosing a higher carat center stone is one of the most common ways people upgrade their engagement rings. Perhaps now that the two of you are in a more successful spot in your lives, a 2-3 carat diamond is easier to save up for and splurge on than it was at the beginning of your marriage. This upgrade is especially excellent for those who enjoy the overall look of their ring but want something a little grander.

Change to a Different Diamond Shape

As there are several diamond cuts to choose from, picking a different one will completely change the overall appearance of your engagement ring. This is a great way to upgrade your ring if you like the setting but want to exchange a classic round cut for a geometric princess cut diamond that features contrasting light and shadow. Changing the center stone shape may be the exact refresh that will satisfy your aesthetic with a gorgeous new diamond that you can admire for many more years.

Add Extra Diamonds

Maybe you love your ring how it is, but you still wish that it sparkled a bit more. Perhaps the upgrade your engagement ring needs are some additional accent diamonds along the band. They could be applied using the pave, prong, or channel settings if your ring design allows it. Gemstones can also give these rings an interesting spark that might have been missing before. Subtle accent stones or diamonds covering the band may be the upgrade you may want.

Change the Setting

Perhaps your style has evolved, and the style of ring you loved when they proposed now feels outdated or does not go with how your aesthetic has changed. Adding a halo of diamonds around the center stone or adding two accessory diamonds may be a more fitting sentimental engagement ring for your love story. At the same time, an extravagant ring could be refined back to a stunning solitaire that celebrates the center stone diamond.

Use a Different Type of Metal

Choosing a different precious metal for your engagement ring will completely transform your ring, even if the setting remains exactly the same. Perhaps you want to upgrade your white gold ring to a platinum ring, so it does not need routine rhodium dippings to maintain its color. Purchasing a more expensive material for your ring may be more affordable later in your relationship than at the beginning. It is also likely that as your marriage has grown, your tastes in jewelry will probably have changed as well.

Upgrade Your Engagement Ring at Neugebauer’s Jewelry

We look forward to helping you upgrade your engagement ring in our Neugebauer’s Jewelry showroom. Our professionals can assist you in picking out the features that will best suit the overall look you are wanting to achieve. Visit our Rapid City jewelry store to begin the process of creating the engagement ring of your dreams.

Track Order

Returning Customers

Sign in to your account to track orders and view your order history.

Quick Track

Don't have an account? Enter your order number and email address below to track your order.